Quote:
This week's poll asks:
Should Maori be given ownership rights to New Zealand’s fresh water resource?
Quote:
*Stop moaning and give the whinging bludgers EVERYTHING. Yeah, right! Rob
*This issue should not even be an issue, but be laughed at for a second as a silly joke. I find it hard to believe how stupid National is, thinking that laying down for the greedy iwi will get them votes. This certainly won't get my vote. In fact I might vote with my feet and leave NZ like so many others. Sheila
*How much more is this National Govt going to give away to Maori? Geoff
*No way, they have had enough already. Murray
*Definitely not. Like the seabed and foreshore water resources belong to the nation. Philip
*When are they intending to claim the Moon? Forbes
*No NO NO. When is all this coming to an end? And we just continue to pay pay pay. Governments must learn to be brave and say enough is enough, your bubble has burst, we are moving on to a new future where everyone can enjoy all financial benefits. Gary
*Fresh water should not be owned by anyone single person,group or corporation but should be for all NZers now and in the future. Robin
*The National govt. needs to make a stand regarding Marori claims. Desmond
*These demands will never end. Lets stop now. Barry
*An absolute and totally ridiculous claim. Ground water in NZ comes from rainfall, which is generated world-wide by evaporation of seas, oceans, lakes and streams. For Maori to claim fresh water in NZ is a spiritual right exclusively for them is a frivolous falsehood. Water is Life, we all need it, our bodies are predominantly made up of it, and for Maori to imply that non-maori do not have an equal right, is seditious. Come on Ministers, grow some balls and kick this into touch immediately. Vic
*Ayn Rand once said something to the effect that any attempt to make a compromise with evil can only ever result in more evil. That is a perfectly logical and true conclusion.
It applies equally to trade unions and Maori. Both will “negotiate” to further their demands and avidly grab any concessions made to them which, they will say, are now set in concrete – never to be changed. Meanwhile any concession they make is only temporarily observed, if at all. It will come up for re-negotiation the next time they dream up a grievance. It is a strictly one-way street leading in the direction they wish to go.
In the case of Maori it is also a cul-de-sac which can old end in their taking-over control of New Zealand lock, stock and barrel. The more outspoken of them actually state that as their aim. But they are scorned as radicals who will never attain their aim. Well – the laugh is on Key and his equally naïve mates – it is happening, steadily, on their watch! Ron
*Maori never owned NZ. Maori deprived those here before them of any Rights by murder and plunder. All natural resources are and should be held and protected by the crowm for the people. John
*Water was not and never will be created by Maori. It is created like the air we breathe by nature to sustain life for all on this earth.It disgusts me that Maori think they have the right to claim ownership of naturally occurring elements. Next it will be the air we all breathe. Gary
*Not unless they can scupper the privateisation nonsense. Christopher
*NO NO NO..I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT IT COULD EVEN BE CONTEMPLATED...WE ALL NEED WATER TO EXIST...IT BELONGS TO ALL NEW ZEALANDERS EVEN THOUGH WE HAVE TO PAY FOR IT THROUGH THE WATER COMPANIES BUT AT LEAST IT HONEST...NO AGAIN NO...STAND UP KEY AND DON'T BE GUTLESS IN THE FIGHT FOR ALL OF US AND NTO JUST MAORI. AUDREY
*Can anyone satisfactorily give me a clearly understandable reason why these people, who call themselves Maori (but in fact are of mixed parentage, with as much European as Maori or more European than Maori) attempting a bluff that they can claim the fresh water?
Pre-European Maori didn’t own land or water - they didn’t exploit it either! Why should anyone exploit it now? (That is ANYONE!)
We should all look after it and use it wisely. Roll on having binding referendums where politicians have to return to being servants of the people - majority rule NOT who has the “power and or money!”
Roll on to when this “Maori” action of pulling the wool over gullible politicians and bureaucrats eyes stops.
Might I add, that the media are largely responsible for giving such rubbish traction that it ought never have had! It's already gone too far with all the Treaty claims!
I'm a New Zealander as much as any of them are. They need to remember they cannot pretend their European ancestry doesn't count. If it wasn't for the European side of their ancestry - they simply wouldn't exist - I'm talking genetics here! Rod
*Absolutely not. Our fresh water resources belong to every NZer on an equal basis. Sarah
*Isn't this getting ridiculous. The greedy maoris at it again and unfortunatly they are dealing with a spineless power hungry John Key. So if not enough rain falls to satisfy the greedy maoris, we will be in even more strife? Neil
*This resource belongs to all NZ citizens. Allan
*Definitely not, how can anyone own something that has been dropping out of the sky since time began. Ian
*Definitely NOT How can anyone own water? It is a moving substance flowing on all the time so it is not still long enough for anyone to own Will the Maoris ever stop their quest for greed? Judith
*Nobody should be allowed to own the fresh water resource. Helen
*Absolutely not. Another rort!!! And while I am commenting I object to Whanau Ora being funded by taxpayer funds. Why isn't it funded from the hefty payouts given to Iwi. Weren't we told those payments would assiat Maori better themselves? How appropriate then that they fund their own to do that and stop bleeding taxpayer funds. Margaret
*A ridiculous agreement. Peter
*They shouldn't be given anything until they pull their socks up as a race but...as per usual, most Kiwis you speak to are too lazy or dumb to stand up for their rights and any impetus is lost. Easier to move overseas it seems. Peter
*Hell No! Why can't we have someone in parliament alerting the media and public to the real dangers of the maori radicals and these ongoing outrageous claims of owning or having rights to any and everything. Maoris weren't even the first ones living in NZ! Nigel
No, because water belongs to no one. It comes from the sky as a result of condensation, which could have taken place any where. The water in our lakes and rivers could have arrived from Australia, antarctica, the distant Pacific, in fact from wherever the prevailing wind blows from. It then flows into the sea and is disdbursed far and wide, perhaps never to return to NZ. So no one can claim a thing that is so transient. Brian
*One law for all can never happen when ownership rights to anything are based on race. Rod
*This is nothing short of bullyism. Hone
*This Racist Maori ownership crap will go on and on until non-maori New Zealanders have the guts to step out and tell Key and his mates to stop sucking up to Maori. Vern
*It's time all those against this Maori view marched against them. Judith
*When will Maori learn to live in the now, and not in the 1840's. Jane
*Your comments on full and final x 4 was hard to be reminded of and has been foregotten by New Zealanders. We need reminding but it is hard to immagine how with the imature press in the state that it is in NZ. Murray
*Some Maori must be laughing up their sleeves! Today water,tomorrow what about the air we breathe? After all, both are from nature's realm. Sadly, these greedy demands reflect very badly on some Maori. Unfortunately weak government refusing to say NO and facing the fallout of that may eventually result in the creation of a monster. Some would say it already has. Best always to say No earlier rather than later or you bring out the very worst in human nature. Del
*They have already been given too much. Given is the operative word. Brian
*IQ's under 80 prevail - stop the voo-doo no one owns a natural resource. Dennis
*This current campaign by maori is another money grabbing eliteist strategy to exclude the wider population of NZ. Susannah
*Absolutely not. NZ should be ONE - division is dangerous and will ultimately lead to lawlessness and rioting like we see all accross the world. Colleen
*A ridiculous concept. Water is a life force for all creatures and plants on earth. Alan
*Absolutely NOT If this ever happened power prices would skyrocket with their greed. Graham
*Maori are the tail wagging the dog and national are letting mainstream NZ down big time. Peter
*Of course not. As a trout fisherman I can tell you the bulk of people who do not pay for a license is moari and any illegal netting is normally by moari. Daryl
*Where is this one nation one people policy. This government is going from bad to worse. When are they going to have the guts to say enough is enough. How any one could claim the water that comes from evaporation of the ocean and it could be the Indian ocean is beyond me. John
*I believe that this claim to water resources is to establish a new grievance. It is the settlement of this grievance that they realy want. They are after all the assets that the Govt. proposes to sell to the public. They want these assets GIVEN to them as settlement for this dubious "grievance". Of course the Waitangi Tribunal will find a excuse to support the Maori claim. That is a foregone conclusion. Ray
*The next thing will be charging for river use. Wake up pathetic non Maori. Lars
*Errol! Very good point you made. It sort of goes along with our thinking: Neither Maori or European ancestors payed anybody for our Natural resources when they arrived to these shores therefore it is not 'owned' by anybody to be sold by anybody. We doubt very much that the New Zealand citizens would want that principle changed which is what the Iwi are trying to do. If the Government goes along with this it will have major implications for NZ citizens and therefore is not solely for the Government to make a decision on.
We are the New Zealand citizens! Why are we not being given the chance to speak for ourselves? Our thoughts and feelings are our mental property and the Crown and Iwi of our country do not represent them or should assume to do so. We should not have to run around getting signatures to demand a referendum on such a major issue that we are going to end up paying through the nose for and not just financially! Ken & Trina
*Water is a natural resource and should be for the benefit of all NZer's not a greedy few. Keith
*What next? Air? wind? sun? Isobel
*Our Government is giving in too much to the Maori activists. The first, "Full and Final payment", was back in 1947. GW
*No one people should have control of water. What is this country coming to. Looks like some nasty movie plot looming over our heads . John
*Politicians as spineless as John Key will continue to give Maori basically whatever they want. When does the backlash really begin? Roger
*Maori should be acknowledged and their culture protected. But they should not be given any money as that only fuels their desire for more funds. Maori people must acknowledge that they have mixed heritage and that the treaty was between all their ancestors european and Maori. Martin
*We need to stop giving Maori preferential treatment. Barbara
*Certainly not! The idea that any one group of NZers have ownership of, and therefore control over, such a fundamental element of life itself is detestable. It would show contempt for the most basic of human rights. Sue
*There is no such thing as "maoris" in NZ. No special rights either. Barry
*That you even have to ask the question shows how low the vision of the leadership has become -Key must stick to his no-brainer comment and act on it and say 'no' to the racists for the first time [of many no's in the future]. Monica
*This is another "thin edge" and would result in a raft of barriers and restriction to ordinary New Zealanders. What next? Wayne
*No, but why not ? We've already given them the salt-water. Another gravy train, another source of resentment!! Dave
*I fear that it will happen though as Key has not got the guts to say no to these bluggers and the average Kiwi has no idea what is going on. Ronmac