JD wrote:
That's a wierd post Genesis1.
If you ask me this Jesus thing is a bit of a fairy tale that suited the Church (read political powerbase) to tell. ie be good, do as we wish and Jesus will send you to heaven. Gee, you will have us believing in Tanewha next.
The Church has got a lot to answer for (as do most institutions).
JD...Why should I believe you? What are your credentials?
Rose: Fine, but we have an issue here about 'rights'. What is the philosophical basis for rights for anyone...and in particular women? Monica and JD don't appear to want to ground rights in the created status of human beings. Monica certainly doesn't think any unborn woman has any rights at all. I assume both think humans evolved over time, out of slime, by random processes. If so, it's pretty hard to justify 'rights' for anyone at all. As a story on an atheist in 'The Weekender' (DomPost Mag) today said,
'Science alerted him to the theory of evolution, "that humans are essentially another animal developed over time. ...One of the big things about religion is that humans are unique. It underlines Christianity." Science also revealed the massive size of the universe. "We're one small dot in so many galaxies." So...humans aren't unique. They're just animals like any other. Individually, we're just a microscopic dot, living for a microscopic dot of time, on a microscopic dot of a planet, in a ginormous universe, and thus we are utterly insignificant.
Question: Do humans have any value to get excited about? What are rights...and specifically 'woman's rights'? Who determines if rights exist, and if they do, why do they and what are they?
Its all very well to slag off as Monica did bitterly at 'god BS', and as JD did with more good humour, but by doing so they've shot themselves in the foot well and truly. Perhaps rights don't exist and any appearance they do is just that, an appearance - in the same way Dawkins says the design in the universe is only apparent, not real. Perhaps it should be just survival of the fittest/strongest/craftiest as Monica wants with with abortion - adult women are bigger and stronger than unborn women and so can do to the unborn women whatever they like including killing them.