About the Author

Avatar photo

Professor Geoff Duffy

Weather – what are the real causes?


Posted on
By

We live in a day when everyone seems to blame the greenhouse gas GHG carbon dioxide for most weather changes even though its atmospheric concentration is extremely small with about 95% formed naturally. On the contrary, carbon dioxide is the vital aerial fertilizer, whose recent minute increases have produced a 20-30% gain in crop yields and extensive ‘Global Greening’ over the last few decades. Carbon dioxide is also a weak GHG having only 2 absorption zones for incoming solar energy, and only 2 for radiant energy coming back from earth. So let’s look at the bigger picture!

All energy comes initially, not as heat, but as electromagnetic energy from the Sun. Then a portion of the solar energy, namely infrared radiation, directly produces heat at the land and ocean surfaces and also with a few atmospheric gases. The other arriving radiation (mainly visible light and ultraviolet radiation totalling about 50%) also ‘impacts’ us on earth in other ways.

More than 70% the earth’s surface is ocean, so solar energy arriving in daylight hours causes a large amount of water to evaporate. The evaporated water-vapour (really a gas) rises, cools, and condenses to form microdroplets which can agglomerate to clouds, mists and fogs (minute water droplets and water vapour). Clouds cover almost 2/3 of the planet at any one time. Some minuscule cloud water droplets amalgamate to produce bigger droplets that fall by gravity as rain. Rain (snow or hail too) cool the air first, then the land and sea. Hence, our ‘liquid-water and water-vapour’ recycle-system adjusts to any changes, and is self-correcting, self-adapting, and self-buffering in our shifting weather processes. Termed the ‘Natural Water Cycle’, it stabilises and moderates the planet’s entire weather behaviour, over-and-above radiation-greenhouse gas GHG interactions.  

Radiation does more with water than just evaporation. A few atmospheric GHG’s can absorb and instantly re-radiate some specific fractions of the infrared radiation component. Water vapour gas is the strongest GHG by far!  Water vapour is actually about 30 times higher in concentration than the total of ALL other atmospheric GHG’s combined. Water vapour is also 100% naturally produced. Unfortunately, it is often overlooked as the weather sentinel, or even totally disregarded in preference for other natural, non-condensing GHG’s (they total less than 0.05% of the atmosphere).

What makes this more amazing is that water vapour is the only atmospheric gas that changes phase as it both condenses to liquid water well as freezes to solid-ice and snow. This occurs mostly without the radiation mechanism in play as it also occurs at night. Clearly water is unique in our weather system. GHG’s do not trap or store radiation but instantly re-radiate specific bands (portions) of infrared energy. If energy-trapping were a mechanism as often proposed, then the clouds would warm and soon disappear.

After the top GHG water vapour, the next two significant GHG’s are carbon dioxide (0.042%) and methane (0.0002%) which are mostly naturally produced in relatively small quantities worldwide (vegetation, animals, ocean floor volcanoes, ocean degassing). Some small amounts of carbon dioxide are also produced on a worldwide scale in combustion processes, motor vehicle exhausts, power stations, and industry (total anthropogenic contributions are less than 1/20 of all the carbon dioxide 0.042% or about 20 parts per million, 0.002% total in air). 

Unfortunately, Governments and governmental bodies around the world have focussed on carbon dioxide and methane as the main causes of climate change and weather patterns.  Many are trying to cut them back through zero carbon policies or eliminate the combustion of coal, natural gas, and oil, although they produce a very small total fraction of these low-concentration GHG’s in the atmosphere. This is totally misguided and has resulted in flawed policies, false media statements, and mass hysteria, where protest organisers use ill-informed school children as puppets.

Actually coal, oil, and natural gas currently supply about 80% of the total world’s energy for transport, electricity generation and industry. This percentage is unlikely to change markedly as the worldwide population continues to grow, especially in the developing countries.  At the moment, there is no sizeable economic alternative in sight except possibly for nuclear energy for electrical power generation (already successful as well as safe in ships and subs). Solar and wind energy are intermittent, unreliable, and unpredictable, and their systems are expensive, and worldwide they produce electrical grid-surges and control instabilities. Supporting expensive backup systems like idling power generators or battery storage are needed which are expensive and increase power costs markedly.

In addition to solar energy-GHG interactions, infrared radiation also directly heats the land and everything on it and the oceans. The energy produced is then transferred directly to air molecules by conduction and then convection because air molecules collide with the warming solids and liquid water surfaces. When these surfaces warm from solar radiation, we get breezes, warm moist air rising (thermals), then winds, storms, hurricanes, rain, snow, and more. These changes are huge worldwide and dictate our weather, and hence the climate patterns. Of course, there is a lot more to consider, like overnight and seasonal effects. Weather-changes depend on massive bi-daily tides at a location, or how closely we live to the ocean shore, how far inland, or if we live on hills or mountains or in deserts.

So changes in weather and the subsequently produced climate patterns, result from far more than just direct solar radiation impacting water and water vapour. Clouds act as parasols (sun-umbrellas) on hot sunny days, then dump cold rain or snow all over the world at the amazing rate of 13 million tonnes a second, to cool both the air and the total planet. The rotating earth induces global air movements, winds, storms, rain, hurricanes, as well as El Ninos, La Ninas, ocean currents and ocean conveyor belts, large oscillating atmospheric jet streams, and more. There are underwater volcanoes from tectonic plate shifts, and extra effects from sunspots and solar wind (particles travelling through space) that can impact cloud formation and our weather as well. The moon on its elliptical orbit also affects weather drastically. It is a complex, extremely hard to model accurately, impossible to control, impossible to change completely, and difficult to predict accurately! 

Radiation important?  Yes!  But there is certainly far more that we must consider in order to get the bigger picture on all the real causes of weather change.

REFERENCES:

  1. Radiation:  https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Atmospheric_Transmission.png
  2. Humidity:   http://www.lenntech.com/calculators/humidity/relative-humidity.htm

For more details watch the short YouTube Video presentation: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5Owyggc78UgDQCjboah5ww