About the Author

Avatar photo

Dr Muriel Newman

Who Really Runs the Country?


Posted on
By

Voting for the 2026 General Election is well underway. At the last election, 60 percent of voters had voted by Election Day. It looks as if it could be higher at this election.

There is no doubt the contest between the left and centre-right blocs remains too close to call.

The Opportunity Party could be a deciding factor. As a result of the mainstream media’s disinformation campaign, promoting a dangerous left wing party as ‘centrist’ and a ‘kingmaker’, TOP’s support climbed above the 5 percent threshold to Parliament, potentially giving the left-bloc a greater chance of winning the election.

Strategic voting is also making predicting the election more difficult – and while the left has received little media criticism for the practice, that’s not the case for the centre-right.

The Maori Party’s call for supporters to split their vote by backing their candidates with their electorate vote while giving their party vote to Labour or the Greens looks likely to deliver up to five of the seven Maori seats. This would create a five-seat overhang in Parliament, requiring the Coalition to secure 63 seats to win the election.

For those wanting a second term for the Coalition, the prospect of split voting has only arisen because National’s party vote has collapsed from 38 percent at the last election to around 28 percent, while its electorate vote is holding steady with the Party on track to retain 37 or more of its 44 electorate seats.

On those numbers, if National’s party vote slips below 33 percent, it is too low to deliver any list MPs. That means all National’s party votes will be wasted – they will not add a single MP to the Coalition, nor contribute in any way to its re-election. Only voting for ACT or New Zealand First would do that.

So, based on current polling, with the Maori Party’s overhang and TOP hovering above the threshold, the only way centre-right supporters can secure a Coalition win is through splitting their vote – voting for National candidates in the electorates to maximise the number of National MPs and giving party votes to ACT or New Zealand First to ensure no centre-right party votes are wasted.

For many New Zealanders, however, choosing who to vote for will be determined by how well they believe the sitting government has performed.

Right now, voters are assessing the Coalition’s record, weighing up its achievements against its shortcomings, and deciding whether to support National, ACT and New Zealand First for another three years, or whether to give Labour, the Greens, the Maori Party, and TOP (if it doesn’t slide below 5 percent) the chance to run the country.

That’s how democracy is supposed to work.

But before passing judgement on the Coalition’s performance, it’s worth asking a more fundamental question: How much power does an elected government actually have to implement the programme voters elect them to advance?

Most people assume the answer is straightforward: political parties campaign on promises, win elections, form governing alliances, and then work out plans to put those policies into effect. This is exactly what the Coalition did in 2023, when they entered office with a clear mandate to reverse the disastrous agenda enacted by the Ardern-Hipkins Government.

But while voters wanted swift action, progress was often slower than expected, with some reform areas barely touched.

Naturally, the failure to advance election promises in a timely manner is attributed to ministerial and government incompetence.

National, in particular, copped the blame for the Coalition’s lack of progress in delivering the reforms voters expected, especially around co-governance, Treaty activism and race-based privilege. Its slide in the polls reflects a growing perception that, when it comes to contentious issues, the party lacks the backbone to honour its election pledges.

But there’s another factor that also deserves consideration, and that’s whether the actual machinery of government is fit for purpose.

Between election promises and policy outcomes sits an expanding bureaucratic minefield of officials, procedures, protocols, institutional interests, and entrenched conventions – all designed to resist changes to the status quo.  

In addition, activist judges, unions, and the media, are all capable of significantly influencing the agenda voters endorsed at the ballot box.

In other words, while the elected Government is held accountable for outcomes, in reality, their ability to control the institutions responsible for delivering them, is limited.

Activism within the public sector was, in fact, something voters were particularly concerned about in the run up to the 2023 election. They had seen the Wellington bureaucracy explode during the Ardern era from 46,000 when they took office to 65,000. And, with many of the new recruits hired, not on merit, but on the basis of “diversity, equity and inclusion” – to advance Labour’s radical identity politics and He Puapua agendas – they called for reform.

However, instead of cutting numbers back to 2017 levels, National prevaricated – and we witnessed the results in obstruction: directives issued by Ministers to fulfil election promises such as prioritising English over te reo, or delivering public services on the basis of need, not race, largely ignored.

But evidence is now emerging that the problems associated with a hostile bureaucracy are far more serious and widespread than previously realised.

The public policy think tank, the New Zealand Initiative, has undertaken research which suggests a “bureaucratic priesthood” is operating within the public service. These power­ful Wel­ling­ton officials think they, not the demo­crat­ic­ally elec­ted government, should judge what the pub­lic wants and what it’s going to get.

Over 700 current and former public servants were surveyed for the study, which is due to be released in mid-November.

Early findings indicate that only 30 percent of public servants believe their job is to serve the elected government, with 70 percent agreeing with the statement that “the public service serves the public, not the elected government”.

Only 60 percent agreed with the state­ment that “because min­is­ters are demo­crat­ic­ally elec­ted, they should decide policy”, with 40 percent of pub­lic ser­vants believing that they, rather than the elected administration, should be the ones to determine Gov­ern­ment policy.

With more than half of all policy advisers, managers and leaders surveyed believing that if they disagreed with the direction of the Government, officials should “brief stakeholders and the media so a minister’s policy becomes politically untenable”, it is no wonder that leaks and other forms of bureaucratic disloyalty repeatedly undermined the Coalition’s reform agenda.

So, while the Pub­lic Ser­vice Code of Con­duct states that pub­lic ser­vants must act in a polit­ic­ally neutral man­ner and respect the author­ity of the Gov­ern­ment of the day, it seems that for a majority of key public servants, personal views over-rode professional conduct resulting in the deliberate obstruction of the Government’s mission to deliver on their 2023 election policy pledges.

Under our constitutional arrangements, public service officials are expected to provide free and frank advice to Ministers. In that role, they are expected to challenge assumptions, identify risks, expose weaknesses and test whether proposals are workable. But once Ministers have made their lawful decisions, officials are expected to implement them professionally, regardless of personal preference.

However, it now appears, that a substantial number of public servants do not accept a central principle of representative democracy – that because elected ministers carry the mandate of the people, they have democratic legitimacy and are entitled to determine policy. Officials with no mandate have no such legitimacy.

This week’s NZCPR Guest Commentator, Dr Oliver Hartwich, the Chief Executive of The Initiative, believes ‘the machinery of government’ has seized up and must be reformed – as he explains in his article, “If I Were PM”:

“The New Zealand state can no longer carry out big reforms in the time it has in between elections. Before promising anything new, someone should ask what got in the way of all the earlier promises.

“You do not have to look far: New Zealand has 43 government departments, 28 ministers and more than 80 ministerial portfolios. Norway, hardly a failed state, governs with 20 ministers and 17 ministries.

“Ministers can neither appoint nor remove the chief executives of their departments; that power belongs solely to the Public Service Commissioner. No minister even works inside the department they lead. All of them sit in the Beehive, which is better suited to the game of politics than to directing public officials.

“My work programme for the first 100 days would start right there. On day one, I would cut the number of portfolios to fewer than 20. In the same week, my ministers would move across the road, into the departments they are responsible for. A minister who walks the corridors of her own ministry learns more in a month than a year of briefing papers will ever tell her.

“The move would also make clear who works for whom.

“The most contentious step comes next. I would abolish the Public Service Commission and let ministers choose the leadership of their own departments. The rules that keep the career public service below them neutral and professional would be tightened, not weakened.

“Critics would call this politicisation. It is not. A minister who answers to Parliament for a department should decide who runs it.”

It turns out that by having limited political involvement in the appointment of departmental heads, New Zealand is an outlier. Other democracies allow Ministers to have a major say in who runs the departments they are held accountable for.

The public service, however, is not the only institution that can prevent the government from delivering its mandate.

Concerns have also been raised about the courts. New Zealand’s constitutional conventions are clear: Parliament, which is accountable to voters, makes the law, and Judges, who are not accountable to voters, interpret and apply it. And while judicial independence is fundamental to the rule of law, so too is judicial restraint.

The Supreme Court, in particular, has, however, become increasingly politicised – moving beyond interpreting legislation into the realm of lawmaking: as evident in their attempt to stop the Coalition from passing the Marine and Coastal Area Act amendment to prevent the tribal capture of our coastline, and in their use of the Ellis case to effectively corrupt the Rule of Law in New Zealand by unleashing “tikanga” or Maori custom as ‘first law’.  

But it’s not just the public service and the courts that can prevent a government from delivering on its agenda. Powerful unions affiliated to the Labour Party and embedded within the institutions of government can also derail progress – especially when working in cahoots with biased journalists, almost 90 percent of whom self-identify as ‘left wing’.

While the public wants the news reported in an unbiased manner, with both sides of an argument presented so they can make up their own minds, most journalists now regard ‘educating the audience’ as their primary role. That means that even if a government succeeds in overcoming bureaucratic resistance, union opposition and legal challenges, if every reform introduced is routinely reported as controversial, divisive, harmful, dangerous, underfunded, racist, anti-Treaty, or a threat to vulnerable groups, public confidence can erode long before any objective assessment of results becomes possible.

In such circumstances, success becomes politically irrelevant if voters have already been persuaded by the public service, the unions and the media that failure is occurring.

Those are the underlying forces that have been shaping the Coalition’s performance: a bureaucracy that has frustrated implementation, courts that have rewritten legislation, unions that have obstructed reform, and a media that has defined success as failure before results are even known.

Democracy is not just about electing governments – it’s also about ensuring they can govern. If the Coalition wins a second term, it needs to address these barriers as a priority for reform.

Because if a government cannot implement the programme it was elected to deliver, we really do need to ask: who on earth is running our country?

Please note: To register for our free weekly newsletter please click HERE.

THIS WEEK’S POLL ASKS:

*Do you believe unelected institutions such as the public service, courts, unions and media now have too much influence over the ability of elected governments to implement their policies?

 

*Poll comments are posted below.

 

*All NZCPR poll results can be seen in the Archive.

 

Click to view x 120

THIS WEEK’S POLL COMMENTS

It is a sinister creeping cancer – does not represent responsibility, truth, what is best for the taxpayers. or the people paying. Emphasis is on Idealism, my rights, it’s all someone else’s fault, – geared negative when we should be driving positive. You can only claim what you have actually earned – cultures are worked for and earned – there is no other upward pathway.Maurice
Parliament is the law maker not the Supreme Court.Phil
Yes, I truly fear for our country’s future. Our democracy is being undermined in every way.Audrey
Far too much, just do their work, they not elected or qualified to make decisions. get rid of most of them, gravy trainers.Rod
Probably because the Politicians require the advice.Warren
They are running/ ruining the countryRick
Absolutely. A totally disgrace.Karl
The long march through the institutions has advanced non-stop for decades!Brenda
It seems appalling to me that the public service, which is undoubtedly full of “Leftards” remains employed despite which Coalition Bloc is in power & l agree with the comment made in this NZCPR Newsletter that MP’s in charge of a Portfolio ought to be able to select their own public servants, so as to have dedicated loyalty from these Taxpayer paid workers, working not only for the MP, but also us…”Joe-Public”…Bruza
“They” are poised ready to go hard again should the Left prevail on Election DayGlenn
Thank you your article is spot on and applies to most of the western world democracies no wonder the west is in such a mess media and unions are controlled by big business Black Roack Vanguard, Star Street, JPMorgan ect which controls assets worth $26 trillion more than the GDP of the US. They manipulate the world politicallyMark
unelected institutions should comply with elected Party policy.ben
Yes, they do.caren
All need to follow the lead of the government in power as they did for Jacinda and seem to believe that she is still there!!!!tony
Yes, otherwise see you later, bye!Neil
Get rid of the dead heads. Why should those who fail to follow directions not be sacked for serious misconduct?Terry M
More Civil Engineering, Less social engineering.Tjaart
What a shambles., they should not have any influence whatsoever.david
And many of the top beauracrats also belong to and attend globalist gevents and groups that adhere to UN agenda 2030Tom
So why did the Coalition, National in particular, not legislate to stop key individuals blocking progress by sacking them as need arises? Who runs this Country?Greg
This is obvious. You are correct that following the 2023 election the coalition government had a mandate in the areas mentioned in your column. I when talking to friends, on numerous occasions we have agreed the government has not acted on their mandate. We are disappointed.Carl
Socialism – Communism do not work.Michael
This is a frightening state of affairs for a democracy! This is what I call,true investigative journalism. Bravo.John
clean them outmartin
Right wing government needs to be much more determined in getting their policies into action.Michael
corporations they have been corporatised even the police , local councils the govt all coroorations for profit stuff the peoplemike
Oliver has been saying this for several years but the Govt. hasnt had the courage to implement itcolin
Dream on Oliver Hartwich, if onlyMonica
The Media is in total control FAVOURING THOSE TO THE LEFTSheryl
They have all made things difficult for the coalition and more particularly Chris LuxonLaurie
The Public Service in particular needs reining in.Pamela
Government needs to shape up.Geoff6
Yes and they need to be removed and no big departing packages. It blatantly stands out leading up to this election. All out in the open for everyone to see.Kevan
Absolutely, read any newspaper. Watch MSM news. How do these people sleep at night ?Dennis
YES, FAR TO MUCH.COLIN
Way too much!MARK
Ministers should appoint the CEO of departments AND be able to fire them for misconduct or obstructionRob
It’s become a case of the ‘Tail wagging the Dog”Bruce
DefyChris
Oliver is correct. The appointed Minister should be able to run his dept as a business. Staff do as instructed or resign or be sacked. NO OTHER OPTIONSNoel
Yes they do and it’s about time Governments had some balls to stop this carry on.ROB
luxon promised to sort this lefty crap out but being a woke pm and gutless the lefties got worse so if labour and all the bent corrupt small parties get in we may as well change our flag to the hammer and sickle.Richard
They will send NZ back 180 yearsSteve
ministers must have the power to select , hire & fire senior civil servants in departments for which they are responsible . I t is a no brainer.Bruce
Absolutely !!! Our politicians are too gutless to deal with all of them. The way our election may go is worrying in the extreme — God help NEW ZEALAND.Alan
Infiltration from unions left based policies disrupting the political agenda Education Health and LawBrenda
Look no further than health care regulators and their cultural safety standards!Angela
Absolute nightmare.meg
And that is why Ardern gr ew the bureaucratic by so much! In order to entrench Marxism in New Zealand no matter which party governs. But Willis and Luxon failed to act early… instead choosing “death by a thousand cuts” as opposed to a far better sudden change in their first year of government Luxon and Goldsmith maintained Ardern’s taxpayer-funded support for opposition TV1 and other legacy media, and further entrenched preferential treatment for Maori and the Waitangi Tribunal that should have been wound down. Why did National and NZF oppose Act’s “Treaty Principles Bill”?Peter
Absolutely. In NZ the elected are led by the nose by the unelected bureaucrats contributing to election promises not being met.Hugh
They are Public Servants – with Emphasis on the word SERVANTS.Denis
I simply cannot agree that unelected people should make any rules for us all. Democracy is not perfect, but it’s the best system we have.Ray
PLEASE RESTORE PROPERTY DEMOCRACY TO NEW ZEALAND!Sylvia
A clean out of the public service, judicial service, unions and media cannot come soon enough. The long march though the institutions is complete; a hard quick clean out is required. Be brave or lose our democracy.Aam
I certainly doMary
kidding right? erica stanford is still subsidising BIG-TIME schools that pledge 3 hrs or more maori prayers each week- 3- 5 interruptions per day… nz, you are lostmark
it is scarey that at the moment and until parliament resumes, these “public service” anti govt crooks have free rein. Who is monitoring this? Certainlynot out crooked meciamurray
Definitely! So it’s time for change.Norma
Like your change in policy. I have seen firsthand the failed policies within the Civil service and agree 100% to your proposed changesJohn
Plus there are far too many ministries and “departments” for the size of NZ. They need to be drastically reduced.Ian
Our bureaucracy is embarrassingly large and growingTristan
This has been glaringly obvious since this govt came into power and I personally have been disappointed with Chris Luxon for not sorting right from the startStanley
As evidenced by the coilitions lack of progress on Hu Puapua and any other cultural/DEI changesHilary
These organisation’s have run rampant over government for many many years. Time for a major change.Sheila
National’s current problems really started with the Key government, when after getting elected with the promise to remove the Maori seats did the exact opposite. The last election was the same promises made but not kept.Hugh
Hardly surprising that leftist drongos appointed by leftist politicians would hamper dutifully elected conservatives. Sadly Luxon hasn’t the balls to sack these parasites.John
A lot of them need to be fired!Glenda
I’d suggest as a minimum we need a mechanism to recall or fire activists Judges & stop government funding of the press!John
A no-brainer!Gary
Obviously!! The bureaucracy can be tackled first and most “easily,” and the suggestions made in this article are a very good starting point. Handling the ideologically captured courts is more difficult and may take considerable time and effort. The unions? No good answer occurs to me. It would be wrong to ban them. The only way I see to address the issue is to persuade the membership to see things rationally and understand what their proper role should be. And instrumental in doing that — in fact, in initiating ANY real reform is the media. I despise censorship or media regulation, so what is to be done? RNZ is the place to start. If it can’t be unbiased, and I don’t think it can, it should be defunded. (Well, maybe not the concert program! We need it to soothe our nerves!) But seriously, what else can we do? Any suggestions?Marla
Harden up and sort the corruption out. Sack the lot of them that will get their attentionJohn
Media funding should be cut and courts should stick to knittingChris
They are now corrupt and follow UN/WEF dictates and are busy installing World Government requirements. Betraying New Zealand as a whole. They also selectively employ their deviant kind. Nero and Caligula couldn’t have done better. ‘Rome’ is again in serious trouble.Bryan
massive reform is urgently neededAnthony
For our country’s sake put a stop to it. Develop backbones and do your job… if you get re-elected! God help us if it is too late!ray
Without dramatic change our beautiful country is doomedDenise
It has been happening for a long time!Peter
Especially the media are so leftist they haven’t reported anything in favour of the present coalition. This is why popularity has plummeted despite all the good they’ve done.Rae
Repeat history – it worked – “Early Parliaments (1854%u20131890s): During this period, members of Parliament (MPs) stood as independents rather than as members of formal political parties.” ie there were no political parties. The majority of Local Govt operates in this manner now.Magog
Very obvious in Local Government as well as Central GovernmentMarie
Absolutely they do ! -the teacher unions for example seek to influence education policy and Labour are now saying that politics should be kept out of education, shorthand for allowing the teacher unions to dictate policy direct to government.Roger
Time the beauracrats influence on ministers was reigned in.Lois
The only solution is to reduce the size of the bureacracy dramatically and get the government out of our daily lives. Regulations require regulators – bureaucrats. Deregulate & you necessarily reduce the bureaucracy. It is actually the only wayMark
ABSOLUTILY!Martin
Sir Humphrey Appleby is alive and well and living in Sir Brian Roche’s body.Doug
Time is well overdue to drain the (Wellington) swamp.Trevor
We’ve become a country where its virtually impossible to fire anyone without it going to court and therin lies the problem.Laurine
Of couse unelected institutions must not have power or influence over elected governments. They have become corrupt and have opened the country’s government to out side control. A few bribe here, some dirt there, and you control a country, easy.Peter
Absolutely!!!! Don’t listen to MSM!!! Anyone undermining Government are bias, bigoted and prejudiced. MSM have become activists.Dianne
We need the courts to adjudicate on controversial matters. We need to uphold the doctrine of the separation of powers and use the courts to this end.Janet
These institutions are long overdue for an over hall. The question remains why hasn’t this been delt with previously. There is more than enough evidence to warrant a new direction. A new broom is required and the sooner the better.Chris
Take Brook Van Velden’s case for example……..with the fire chief!Neville
FAR TOO MUCH !!sandra
An army of white ants eating away at our democracy while carrying on with their agenda regardless of any centre-right reformist government ‘policy’.Francis
It has got to StopGraeme
Clearly that is the caseBruce
Along with the Waitangi Tribunal all bad for our countryClaire
All lean far to far to the left.Richard
We are not alone in this phenomena,clearly UK and USA have had similar issues .Wayne
De-powering these organizations is critical to the success of a true democracy.Robert
The elected govt should be voted in to run our country but it has become too complicated for the average person to make the correct decision so its anybodys guess what will happen.Barbara
I sincerely hope the coalition win another term with larger representation for ACT and NZ First, and that between them they mage a clean out of the country.Sue
Yes , absolutely, the courts & media have free reign & are not adhering to the governments wishesMike
The Public Service has always had a lot of power to stall government policies, but now the courts are, disgracefully, interfering with government. The media is a total disgrace. Far from being fair and balanced reporters, seeking the truth, supporting democracy and holding truth to power, they are left-wing ideologues, hell-bent on destroying democracy! Shame on them all!!!Donna
and widespread reorganisation and reduction of ministries and portfolios is essentialGordon
You missed “Maoris” in your list of “institutions”Ian
Auckland Council is basically running the Country, and applying TaxesPieerre
Yes, without a doubt, although this is a loaded question. Luxon will likely lead the coalition to defeat for not accepting the value of spit voting. Memo to Luxon: NEW ZEALANDERS ARE NOT STUPID, BUT YOU MAY WELL BEPeter
It has been blatantly obvious when the right is in power. The institutions we, the public own, attack our sanity and commonsense every which way. It should be that a new broom sweeps clean.Jeff
YES! DEFINITELY. It will be courageous politician who carries out the remedy needed. A drastic pruning or sacking of the most influential replacing them with the new incoming government. They are there to serve the government of the day, not tell them what to do. There must be a factor in the system that holds them accountable – nothing like threat of the three year election razor focussing their minds.Donald
For far too long !!Geoffrey
This has got worse the last 3 years as Mr Luxon is too weak to stand up to them and other elements he promised to curtail prior to the last election. Hence – this is a major reason why National if performing poorly in the poles.Chris
We need these institutions to be neutral as they are supposed to be. 17%of the population shouldn’t have all the rights.Jill
They certainly do. Ministers should be driving the policies they were elected on to ensure they are followed through in the public service and courts. The only minister who looks to me to do that is the minister of education who has had unbelievable resistance even though the changes she has pushed through were consulted on with the help of a selection of teachers and principals.Keith
Ministers should be able to appoint CeOs of government departments. They need to have confidence that the CeO of the department will follow government directives. But they should also investigate the departments CeOs who don’t follow government agendas and those should be sacked immediately. The same with the media, which is so powerful not only in NZ, but in the rest of the world. Every month an analysis of fairness and unbiased should be analysed and any media that shows bias should be fined millions of dollars. In relation to judges, their decisions that attempt to take the role of the legislative, government should strength the role of the organisation that handles complains about judges decisions that take the role of the legislative. Severe penalties, including dismiss should be implemented . This organisation would have to be truly monitored, to ensure that they are correct in distinguishing the role of the judiciary from the legislative. Decisions that are taken the role of the legislative should be immediately annulled.Peteca
A complete free for all against the democraticaly elected coalition . I recently recieved an email from a party from the coalition asking for money to get their message out because the MSM wouldnt ablige , I replied “dont winge to me about it youve had 3 years to sort the scum bags out, if youd done what you promised to do we woudnt be more than a littel nervous going into this election”. Yes I know the bastards have infiltrated every thing they can but with 6 years in opposistion and now 3 years governing and you still cant cut the mustard.Iam only voting for you guys because the alternative is to frightening to comprehend.The biggest word in the dictionary is IF. IF double agent 00 zero cluckson wasnt leading the nats? IF the MSM were neutral , IF kiwis wernt so appathetic …..The only decision National needs to make is “do we want to be cremated or buried”?. IF by some miracle you retain your posistions as leaders of this wonderful country , we the people will hold you to the fire until you fulfil your obligations and promises if not we will warm ourselve whilst we watch you burn 1 LAW FOR ALL.GLYNJ
Like most western countries, New Zealand is no longer a democracy. The governing party in this country is the unelected and unelectable lanyard clad New Zealand Public Service. Parliament is but a sideshow where the clowns help keep the peasants gaze averted. If by a fluke the present government is re-elected it should immediately defund TVNZ and Radio NZ – something it should have done on entering office three years ago.David Jones
This country has been captured. Even the Electoral Commission looks suspiciously biased. Look closely at the slanted adverts we’ve been subjected to of late and listen to some of the alarming stories of irregularity around voting.Geoffrey
the whole public service has shown that they need a major cleanout.Nigel
Yes, most definitelyMurray
To me, the worst example was an unidentified (and never held accountable) civil servant inserting the UNDRIP clause into the India FTA.Noel
Yes they need to be culled!John
We select our government so let them govern without any influence from unelected groups.Dianne
Absolutely, there was never a honey moon period for the current coalition. Future generations will pay the price for their left wing socialist activity.Lawrie
As I see it, this country’s mixed up politics has come about by weird leadership, over recent years whose displayed goals seem to have been to socially and racially divide New Zealand for nefarious reasons – those reasons have run contrary to those which campaign dialogue did NOT include! What politicians can be trusted?Stuart
What Arden infiltrated into the public service has to be rooted out.Lindsay
Yes they do.Murray
Why should unelected people wield so much power.Barbara
The difference between Humans and Animals – Animals never allow a fool to lead the pack.WSCGraeme
Senior public servants should be on three year contracts, aligning with election periods.Peter
This Election is turning into a TOTAL MESS- As an 83 yearb OLD true BLUE CWilliamitian Iv NEVER sean SUCH a BALLS UP ELECTION ##Willey
I agree with Oliver Hartwitch; abolish the Public Service Commission and let Ministers select their staff.Peter
Absolutely. It’s in all councils, all govt departments. All the banks. The media.Janet
Hell yes. Or would it be more appropriate to YES MINISTER! These institutions thumb their noses at Government ordinances. They run the place and can’t be either held to account or be voted out. A complete GRAVY TRAIN.Simon
I find the trade unions advertising against National clearly a breach of reasonable non biased woke behavior .Sadly the Tyrant Adern still permeates through New Zealand ,she continues blissfully on ,as does the homosexual Robertson ,both getting exorbitant paying jobs whilst the fabric of New Zealand continues to struggle ,with their woke destructive separist agendas forced on us . The unions are clearly communist focused ,dont even start on the judiciary or school teachers woeful history of demonstrating against right wing policies ,shame they dont treat teaching children with such enthusiasm . One can only hope time will enlighten Kiwis to our sad state of affairs.Ray
Yes and it is ruining the country.Fraser
Yes, get back to basics. Kim
This has been going on for years. Its just more noticeable now. problems were there 30 years ago when I was in local politics. The local government association have a lot to answer for.Joan
It has become quite obvious that those named in THIS questionaire are indeed running our once wonderful NEW ZEALAND and rapidly stuffing it. Brian W.Brian
that is why the country is in so much shit withall theses radial trying to push there ideas.Barry
It’s essential that Ministers know exactly what is going on and absolutely should be able to choose their own ministry heads.Jan
Especially when it comes to pushing Te Reo and Maori spiritual voodoo fairy dust myths that suit their agenda.Wayne
too many little hitlers who think they no better, than the people voting in Government.Chris
Public servants need severly culling. Most are not needed.Neil
Without any doubt. Needs to be stamped on as an urgent priority as currently these organisations are just running over the top of Government. TVNZ and RNZ need to be commercialised and the Universities also put in their place.Allan
It has been evident for some time. Are the politicians tough enough to fix it soon?ken
Radicals appear to be entrenched in Government departmentsPeter
Have done for a long timeGail
AbsolutelyAllan
Im sick of it. Getting out while the dollar is still worth 50C. three time the Dollar will be replaced with a Maori coinc which will be worth nothing. The NZ public are getting what they desereve. All the fools who beleive the lies of hypo Hoppkins.Tony
far too much inflence…for far too long.. unles its a left-leaning gummintGill
Yes but why? Unlike Norway we are not a sovereign country. Who really runs NZ? Look at UN, He PuaPua. NZ is controlled by powers outside of our country. I am disappointed you never address this fact.Marie
yes but how can that be changed now. It’s embedded in our society.mike
Far too much, especially the media.Neville
Your conclusions as with Oliver Hartwich’s, are more than obvious.PETER
yes if they buck parliamentary Laws they should be fined big dollars, wth no concessions .TONY
Yes they do. We voted for whichever Government results after a free election to implement heir policies. God Defend New Zealand.Bruce
Far too much!Maria
The current system is crazyIan
The pasty three years is a clear example mom this fact.Douglas
The Public Service see themselves as the ‘UPPER HOUSE’ of Parliament, directing how legislation is to be interpreted and applied.Bob
Replies to several OIAs reflect left wing views rather than following the legislation, as written. The issues may be minor BUT the implication is major. We know better than the actual legislatipn. We therefore can interpret the law as we see fit tather than as legislatprs intended.Margaret
tO MUCH INFLUENCE IS GIVEN BY THE UNIONS AND GREENS ETCColin
They are all following the Fabian agenda!james
Its totally unfair that unelected media, unions judges and beauracrats should be swaying and making their voices loudly heard above our elected MPs. Limiting the actions of MPs. Plus influencing the opinions of the general public.Rosemary
MMP is also in the mix along with the Public Servic to blame for the inability of governments to effect change.David
It is a creeping disease that does NOT tell the truth, nor work in the best interests of the persons who are paying for it.Maurice
DefinitelyHelen
ALL of those so-called institutions should back the hell off and leave the Government to do their job. Parliament is supposed to be the highest Court in the Land, so why is it that Judges seem to think that they are the ones to make the decisions? I’m absolutely over interference by these institutions and it’s time to back right off. Is it any wonder that people don’t purchase or listen to their crap anymore?Heather
The real controllers of our country, live outside it. Globalists / bankers / WEF / UN run our country. Governments are simply puppetsGrant
Really importantHugh
Absolutely!Joe
Sack themKevin
The socialist march through the institutions has completed and is strangling this country’s ability to achieve anything. If the centre right get back in they should gut the public service like fish in the first 100 days, cut budgets by 30% and just cop the flak. By the time 2029 comes around the public will have forgotten most of it and they’ll have had two years to spin up the benefits. Another cut should be defunding the treacherous msm including red radio and TVNZ.John
Definitely!!Dr. Alastair
NZ’s left leaning deep state seems to have more power than the current coalition govt.John
Fire all the left leaning public servants and get to a reasonable number, say 25,of servants maxDavid
Far too much influence by institutions outside of Government.Gifford
Yes, It’s definitely become a swamp, which needs draining. Argentina’s reform recipe is a good one to follow.Paul
New governments should be able to fire anyone who won’t implement their policies.Clive
They don’t show the factsJean
All these public service roles, combined with the extremists who have taken over industry, professional, trade & even recreational bodies means that New Zealanders have no rights to be heard. Our democracy is a joke.Fiona
The public service commission needs to be ended in the 1st 100 days. The courts put back in their lane and the media muzzle, and unions stopped.Mark
I question the label “public service”. It’s clear that employees of the government no longer consider themselves “public servants”, and so “push their own political barrow” – especially those who were employed during the Ardern government. And, yes, the media including the government-owned TV1 do not give balanced presentations, offering alternative views, but constantly push their own left-wing perspective.Laurence
Too many dogs wagging their tails……Carl S
I fully agree with the aboveChristopher
unelected public servants simply Ignor the wishes of a government, which should, to achieve is goal, reduce the numbers radicallymalcolm
It is clearly covered in Muriel Newman’s paper. The overriding principle is that Government is elected by the people (electorate) to determine how the Country should be run , NOT the Government Service ; Judiciary ; Waitangi Tribunal or any other similar body. There is far too much race-based activism at large in the Government Service / Departments and others mentioned above – all of which have been deliberately infiltrated by and infested with activists bent on destroying our principal democratic principle / mandate of equality of citizenship before the law. It is Government’s responsibility to ensure this inbuilt bias is TOTALLY ERADICATED from the Government Service etc and objectivity and neutrality fully restored / reinstated.Hugh
This situation is completely ridiculous and shame on the coalition (comprising as it does many seasoned politicians) for not sorting this immediately upon gaining office. Many will pay with their jobs.Tony
we need to reduce the number of Ministers and reduce the amount of Public Sector ministries to reflect the cost our economy can absorb- Make CEOs accountable for budgets and performance as per the private sector. The unelected sectors i.e Judges , Unions and Waitangi Tribunal need to be put back inline with what their roles are a -Judges advocating the law as Government lays out, Unions looking after their delegates and no more -Waitangi Tribunal is an advisory group regarding Maori Grievances-to the Government and no more- As ACT and NZ Frist have campaigned on finish up final settlements then disband the Tribunal.John
It is obvious that the bureaucracy and the judiciary are impeding the government’s delivery of its policies.Kerry
I am con earned at not only this, but also media bias. As if that is not bad enough, having seen first hand the political bias put forth by teachers is a serious reason for not lowering the voting age.Murray
Very much so.Max
This fact also applies to local govts, councils etc.Rex
NZ is run by bureaucrats who ignore government and continue to push for a Maori Parliament.Ken
Time for a big rethinkRuss
As having come from that sector have seen this happening on a daily basis first handMike
Most definitely. And they have been doing so for years. You can also include the Media and the Electoral Commission, who actively work against the current government.Trevor
Yes – this has gone on for far too long. I did not realise the extent until I read Muriel’s and Dr Hartwich’s commentaries. This coming election will be a “make or break”one for NZ – it is imperative that we make the right choices!Scott
National, while achieving some good things, had no courage or backbone to do some of the things that really needed doing. Probably the most disappointing National led government ever.John
Gutless National led governments have been too scared to take on these vested interests. It should be the first thing they do in governmentAndrew
Yes, of course these unelected groups have far too influence. It has mentioned none of them are democratically elected Law makers & there fore have no business nor any right to twist the laws of NZ to their own selfish interests, and this comment especially applies to Maori!! Court Judges are another terrible example where they claim it is more important to be consistent than to uphold the true intention of the Law.Greg
Yes it’s obvious all govt, institutions are run on there own ideology Health,education, it’s rife in all ministries even DOC believes it can decide on the sale of conservation landAlan
Oliver for PM. This is going to take some turning aroundGary
ABSOLUTELY!Murray
They have had too much influence over government’s policies for far too long.Arthur
Definitely.Chris
Why do the MPs not try harder to fix the problem? They need a FIRM LEADERRICHard
The PSA ruled socialists are the biggest blockage to sorting out NZs bureaucratic nightmare. In the last few years the woke judiciary is compounding and confounding the inertia in following govt public policy.mike
Certainly if you have any influence please let them see what is happeningYvonne
Undeniably so.fred
Senior public servants should be fired if they do not comply with government orders . SSC should be the first.Gareth
Absolutely, 100%Dominic
Yes completely NZ is now completely undemocratic and grubby ment in Nz with 120 mps is completely unacceptable and out of controlGreg
Absolutely! Drain the swamp…Maddi
This article is too soft on the Government. They could have done everything they promised with enough resolve.Michael
If I have known this yes answer for over 60 years then so have others. The National Party are responsible for this incompetence.Rex
eye watering stuff. Parliament warrants a complete overhaul.Reg
Yes the public service is a home those mostly concerned with protecting their patch and ideology while relying on consultancies needing the same outcome as they desirePhi
The self-serving NZ political framework has enabled it for decades. Time to increase the accountability levels in both Politics – and Bureaucracy. Taxpayers should expect much more after this election.Andrew
Time for a total clean out. We need honest reporting and the truth.Mark
Absolutely. Parliament is almost powerless to control the Public “Service”. Worse when the National Party follows its long standing practice of merely being a custodian of most of the previous Labour Government policies.Frank
Agree the unelected institutions are taking the COUNTRY OVER IT Needs to be stopped ASP AFTER THE ELECTION BY THE National Govtleo
The Public Service at both the central and Local Govt level require a major restructuring. The Courts should be required to strictly work within the Law no exceptions. The unions and media be held to account for blatant bias.Tony
The people’s voice needs to be heard through their elected M.P’s. Courts, Unions and the media need to just do the job they’re employed to do, not try to sway the public to leftist agendasMary
bring back one nation one peopleMat
Absolutely. Stop giving taxpayer funds to TVNZ and RNZ for a start!Hohepa
No questionDavid
They are but Public Sevants after all !Alan
Not sure about including the court system thoughSue
Far too muchArthur
I agree that Ministers must be able to appoint their own CEOs of Government Ministries.Peter
The tail has wagged the dog for years now in NZ. It’s time we had a government with the will and the strength to reverse this trend and return the country to democratic parliamentary rule. Without this we are on the slippery slope to ruin!TOBY
Absolutely true.DIANE
those that govern need to sort them outNoel
Without a doubtDavid
all are stirred by media input. The country requires mor accountability directly.:mike
it’s NOT up to the courts, union and media to tell the government what to do. The NEWZEALNDERS who live in NZ are the primary people who can by voting the right Party(ies).Dominique Greenslade
These rogue CEOs and senor staff need to be contracted out.Mark
Get rid of them.Harvey
What is the point of having beaurotic officials going against democraticaly elected govenment Policy? Sack and replace them.Andrew
I sure do. If the left gets elected that will be the end of democracy as we know it.The Maori left,labour,greens,opportunity and Maori will run riot and who will pay? The rich,the not so rich and anyone with money,they will have their wealth taken and it will be given to the deadbeats,the homeless,the local market and the rich and poor will just change places. The end result will be a 4th world country.Peter
Take a party like oppertunity who are given a job by a board and do as the board says,calling democracy. It is just as the poliburat runs in Russia. What a joke.Stephen
it has happened in most western countries. USA have the ability to remove them at the start of each term.Nicholas
Same happens in local Government. The CE and staff drive their personal agendas which is more often than not to the detriment of ratepayers.Chris
They have become all.powerful under jacinda and need to be put back under the control of our elected representitavesMichael
Our Democracy has become at far too high a cost.Francis
Yes, undoubtedly! Evidence is seen daily in every media form. Deplorable behaviour by govt departments, media bias, & judicial variance from established Westminster based law instead reflecting primitive ignorant ancient practices!Barbara
Anythingng else is not democratic.Chris
This Action is Vital, Must have steel balls, but certainly what is urgently needed, and would receive massive support Lets Go for it Whats to loose ?clint
ACT Party policy focuses on the reform required to correct this imbalance.Anon
Yes having lived in Wellington most of my adult life I have witnessed the obstruction of due process by a number of unelected public servants One department had a roving trouble shooter on the floor to deal with complaints Heads of departments need to be managed by the government of the day not by their personal beliefs There needs to be change And a four year term would be helpfulBruce
They seem to think that they have the power to run the country and should be put in there place. The problem l think comes from incompetent politicians of last ten years who just have not any idea about common senseMartin
You also need to add in Regulating Bodies, who gag the independant speach of professionals who stand to lose their livelihoods by speaking out, University management, who gatekeep who is employed to capture our children’s minds, and the so called independent Boards of semi- Government bodies, such as Fire and Emergency NZ,david
Globalist tyrrannyRobert
They should be sacked and have to reapply for their jobs based on past performanceTom
Parliament is supreme and should control the public service etc., Not the other way around.Gavin
Personally integrity in respecting employment conditions is ignored in favour of overt or covert activismCliff
Including local governmentRaymond
The media are totally leftist & do not present a fair picture of what is happening at any given time. Councils having unelected members with voting powers is ridiculous. They are all woke Maori activists who would totally screw the country.david
Combined with the media Influence during the election period and three years of push Back from the other groups and the constant polling results with no indications of the questions producing their results democracy has been downgraded. Polls should cease in the 2 weeks prior to the election in my opinion.Pat
There needs to be more accountability of the public service actionsDes
They sure do and the government promised to end it when they got in BUT did nothing I just hope NZ first and Act between them get more seats in parliament this time IF they winPeter
Hate to think where we are going to end up if the ‘mental’ activist socialist, white maori parties – Labour, Greens of Aotearoa, Te Pati Maori and potentially the media’s darling, the dangerous communist Opportunities party.Judy
While i agree with the comment rsgarding the difficulty in getting things done, as in the case of National. it did nt stop Labour and Jacinda in their 3 years.mike
The public service and courts (unless there are legal disputes) should have no influence in a true democracy. Unfortunately, unions and the media are part of a functioning democracy and any suppression will come up against free speech no matter how biased they are.Brenton
In the bigger Picture, Globalists are still very much involve in World Politics and following their 2030 One World Government Agenda !!Geoff
absolutely and have done for a long time,rodger
Getting worseRichard
Way too muchGerry
Govt.Paralysis by a bunch of overpaid low- life snobs.Chris
Too many bureaucrats for a country this sizeEdward
beaurocrats totally out of control and promoting their own agenda.john
They have the power to support or obstruct an elected Government. It would be difficult for them to tolerate a possible 3 year, or even 4 year Term though, so however much we might long for a neutral [or supportive] beurocracy, it wiill be extremely difficult to initiate.Rochelle
Drain the swamp!Peter
I think we should learn from Norway & someone should go over there learn how it operatesCindy
We need to go to a four year voting cycle!! and the managers of the Public service should only have 4 year terms as well so the incoming Government can change them if they wish with out golden parachutes!!Les
Especially the woke courts and leftist mediaYanna
FIRE THEMMike
And have done since the 70’sMike
Yes Minister on steroids. Next government needs to set a 80% clean out target on the replacement or better still redundancy of roles) in the civil service. The media must be totally defunded of public funds.Richard
I agree whole heartedly with your comments, our country is too small to have all these ministries and departments, also the numbers in the public service should be reduced by at least 20%, 25% would be better , but by at least 20%Alec
Unequivocally yes.Tony
I said this all along from the moment go in 2023: A radical purge of all these Labour sown landmines in the institutions plus cutting loose the media and stop state funding for them to create a new start. This- and only this- would have made New Zealand a different place and a better place for that matter. If the current Government is re-elected, they have to do exactly that or we end up in a big pickle.Michael
Our elected ministers are not able to put polocies in place as they are always thawted by the unelected bureaucracy.Marion
MURIEL FOR PRIME MINISTER We have a real COT CASE at the moment going nowhere!!John
The road to third world.Clive
DOC is a prime example doing as they see fit and handing large tracts of land over to Iwi. It is the mere tip of a large unwieldy iceberg sitting near the plimsol line of this curent coalition Govt.John
they are a law unto themselves and must be reigned in.Mike
my sister, a communist, is a GM in a certain Ministry – she implements leftist, docialist policy irrespective of who the government isMerie
REIN IN THE supreme courtDOUGLAS
A case of “Yes minister” on steroids. I agree the departmental head should serve at the pleasure of the minister.Rob
Sack them all and no dole.Evans
Yes,and this leftish pressure on the ruling Gonernment must be removed.Colin
It has become quite apparent that the Courts are following their own agenda and Government Beauracracy is out of control and also following their own agenda and this needs a strong Government to change this direction starting with a 4 year term for GovernmentPeter
However we did have once the ministry of works and they did a magnificent job, as aposed to contracters who seem to charge the earth and never get it done on timeAndrew
This is the reason our country and the government is being held backPatricia
Worse, they actively work against ministers and even lie to them – we have seen examples of this.Trevor
AbsolutelyRobyn
I think public service and unions have too much sway and i think there has been purposeful sabotage by public servants, especislly leading up to the election.Marilyn
Reduce their numbers and let the ministers responsible nominate the department leadersBrian
Far too muchEugene
All department head should tender their resignations when a government changeschris
The civil service effectively a private members club serving iits own members -supported by a leftwing biased mediia that seriously needs an injection of a nationwide publication that provides balanceJulian
It is why the Coalition manifesto in the last election has not been fulfilledMichael
The government should run the country, NOT the bureaucratsJohn
A radical reset is required, less MP’s, Less Depts, Less BureaucratsJohn
Unions and biased media more so have too much influence. News almost always negativePaul
Far too much influence when they should have none at all. They are there to implement what the elected government tell them.Rod
Way too much power. All department heads should have to stand down and reapply for the role each election.Chris
They are definitely seriously influenced by the unelected beaucratsPeter
Those unelected institutions have taken on way to much authority upon themselves, to the point where they are actively obstructing the elected ministers (our representatives) in the lawful running of this country. That has to be reversed. Ministers should have the power to remove and then choose, whomever they want to head the department that they are in charge of. Other countries do that successfully, so why not us?Trevor
It’s been horrifying to watch the influence of the public service, the courts, the unions, and the media have had on the mP’s and the general public. This also happens in Local Government of course. God help new Zealand.Jane
And the PM and his Party had the authority to deal with ALL these issues–but did VERY little to do so. They have been an impediment to our democracy.Bill
absolutely the case…no longer is accountability for outcomes obvious…lying to ministers should be a sacking offence with no payout as should not following directives of ministers. Cutting the public service in the blanket manner marketed by the right is dumb…what is required is elimination of deadweight -ie as per Norway…its a completely different story.Gavin
Half of these people need to go and find real jobs – far too much noise from far too many.Jan
Big changes needed.Graham
The I agree 100.%. The behaviour of them all put together is nothing short of a demolition job on the government. It’s disgustingChris
It is just a shamblesNeville
Dr Oliver Hartwich puts it succinctly. Clean out the public service. Get rid of ardern’s DEI hires and bloated bureaucracy. Get neutrality back into the departments. As for the press l wouldn’t trust fish and chips from them.Peter
Yes, they have taken control of our democracy. All of them, public service, courts, unions and media appear to be running our country. They are all putting up road blocks against our current govt. All need a huge clean out and neutral management installed.Allan
They have far too much influence and openly defy instructions from their minister.BrUcE
Yes, most certainly. There is serious need for the cancer treatment – cut out those impacting on our democracy and the government’s ability to implement policy.Gordon
Absolutely. sack the lot and offer new contracts with NO redundancy clauseBasil
YES… But they are all corrupted now, by the lies and corruption, that have been allowed to seep in and destroy, all the worthwhile aspects of Democracy and freedom, all of which have been destroyed by corrupt officials at the top of our once respectable INSTITUTIONS, that have been destroyed from the inside-out, and are totally corrupted, signs of a system that has become rotten to the core, well past restoration! and a waste of time trying to restore.David
Potentially the to largest problems New Zealand face are:- 1 the effect on our economy that the senseless devotion to climate change by the left the media and National 2 the disregauad of the majority or at least most partys of accepting the challenge of providing for a viable pension scheme for our citizens. Fortunatley at 83 I may not have to face this problem, but it clearly appears all political partys lack the courage to do something about itMike
The country is doomed if the Left bloc get inallan
I am really uncertain who will win this election. I am terrified the left wing parties will get in. I can’t understand how the different burocracies including the courts can somehow get one over the ruling government, there seems to be something terribly wrong with this country now days. I wonder if it is because there are so many activists and socialists who seem to live in our country and believe that they are always right no matter what, it’s so worrying and frustrating, all I know is if Labour and there lefty mates get back in NZ is in alot of trouble.Paul
God I hope soAllan
Yes, they have far too much influence – they have not only obstructed the implementation of the Coalition’s reforms, but they poisoned the general public against them.David
The media are the worst. When Labour was in power, there were hardly any news stories about hospital waiting lists or homelessness, but since the Coalition won office, attack stories have dominated the news. What’s really bad is that TVNZ and RNZ are amongst the worst, and they are State-owned!Maureen
The Coalition should have been tougher in removing activists from the State sector. Almost every government agency now has a radical Treaty division that pushes Maori language and culture onto organisations that should be colourblind and culture-free. These need to be defunded as a priority if the Coalition wins the election.Phil
The influence of these institutions shows why Labour governments have an easier time – their goals are aligned to the majority of left-leaning employees who dominate these sectors. Hugh
The Coalition needs to be a lot tougher and faster in fixing this stuff. They should have done it in 2023, so they had a chance to fulfil all their election promises. Simon